Most churches call themselves 'New Covenant' people—but when you actually read what the New Covenant promises, none of it describes the church. So who is it really for?
Key takeaways
- White argues that the New Covenant in Hebrews 8 is made explicitly with the house of Israel and the house of Judah—not the church—and that no passage in Scripture transfers it to all mankind.
- He walks through each feature of the New Covenant from the Jeremiah 31 quote (law written on hearts, all knowing the Lord, sins remembered no more) and shows that none of them describe the current experience of believers.
- White makes the case that Christians are not under the Old Covenant or the New Covenant—they are in Christ, who is the mediator between the covenants, placing the church in an 'in-between' zone.
- He traces a line of bad theology back to bad terminology: calling the Greek scriptures 'the New Testament' inadvertently placed the church inside a covenant that was never made with them.
- White uses the logic of verse 13—that calling something 'new' makes the other thing 'old'—to show how Paul was making a subtle, scripturally grounded argument to a Jewish audience about the forward-looking nature of their own covenant.
- He distinguishes between things that are 'similar' and things that are 'the same,' noting that forgiveness of sins existed in the Old Testament without those people being under the New Covenant.
Passages
Loading passages…
Read a passage in the Bible panel.
Detailed overview
In this session, Randy White works through Hebrews 8:7–13, with a brief revisit of verse 6, to make a careful and pointed argument: the New Covenant promised in Scripture is not for the church—it is specifically for the house of Israel and the house of Judah. Drawing directly from the extended quote of Jeremiah 31 embedded in the Hebrews passage, White walks through each feature of the New Covenant (God's law written on hearts and minds, all knowing the Lord from least to greatest, sins remembered no more) and asks plainly whether any of those descriptions fit the church today. His answer is no—and he argues that Christians have inherited confused theology partly because of confused terminology, particularly the habit of calling the 27 books of the Greek scriptures 'the New Testament,' which subtly places the church inside a covenant made with Israel. White's core contention is that believers in the church age are not under the Old Covenant, not under the New Covenant, and are not 'covenant people' at all—they are in Christ, who serves as the mediator between the covenants. The session closes with a look at verse 13, where Paul's logic is that naming something 'new' automatically makes the prior thing 'old,' and that what is old and decaying is ready to vanish away—a subtle but deliberate argument aimed at a Jewish audience being invited to consider that their own scriptures point forward to something better.
Summary generated from the episode transcript. Refer to the recording for the full teaching.